干细胞之家 - 中国干细胞行业门户第一站

 

 

搜索
中源协和

免疫细胞治疗专区

欢迎关注干细胞微信公众号

  
查看: 116366|回复: 5
go

CAR-NK是否优于CAR-T细胞免疫疗法? [复制链接]

Rank: 4

积分
1132 
威望
1132  
包包
237  

金话筒 优秀会员

楼主
发表于 2015-11-11 10:59 |只看该作者 |倒序浏览 |打印
干细胞之家微信公众号
作者:疑夕
( s: k5 Q: I& p$ V. ?/ P0 E; g/ D+ l" ]; k# Z: p! U
On December 15, 2014, Patrick Soon Shiong, the richest physician in the world, acquired 19.9% of Sorrento Therapeutics (NASDAQ: SRNE)’s equity at $5.80 per share (about 41.7 million). Four days later, Sorrento and Conkwest announced an agreement to co-develop CAR-NK immunotherapy. Sorrento’s stock price reached a high of $11.38 on January 15, 2015.' T" ]8 A  L0 y. ~/ g6 |! H

, n0 c  D$ m5 p3 f& ~CAR-T cell immunotherapy has been regarded as one of the most compelling breakthroughs in cancer treatment in recent years. Companies working on CAR-T (e.g., JUNO, KITE, BLCM, BLUE, ZIOP) are red hot at present. Sorrento/Conkwest is developing CAR-expressing NK cells rather than T cells to kill cancer cells. How about CAR-TNK compares to CAR-T?
! O  E5 L- r' f" ~4 U, ~
4 w( _2 _8 ~* I, b9 v4 V! W" Q  Q6 UHere is a comparison published in OncoImmunology[1]. The author, Hans Klingemann, is the inventor of the NK-92 cell line and co-founded ZelleRx in 2002, which was renamed Conkwest in 2010. CAR-NK has many several advantages over CAR-T:# C8 s& a# t2 T% p4 M" Y
  a% T4 L6 r7 r: q) c. H2 T- \. Z+ \
(1) CAR-NK cells don’t produce IL-6 which is associated with the cytokine release syndrome. A series of patient deaths in the trials of CAR-T were linked to unusually high levels of IL-6.# n! i- [: l+ a! B. b6 @
6 m2 K4 o. l0 |/ p7 w$ ~
(2) CAR-NK cells disappear relatively rapidly from the circulation owing to their limited lifespan. There is no concern about persisting CAR-associated side effects. Whereas Juno Therapeutics has to insert EGFRt gene into the CAR-T cells to control them.
- ]% r3 I& R% J+ A/ E* D4 b 0 C  B4 o' m9 Y3 r1 f3 T- [
(3) NK cells are known as serial killers which diligently moves from one target to the next one, killing on as many as 7-10 cells.3 T: n* T( P; A& y; M& o

- F* N' g9 }6 x# @$ [& b- P(4) The transfection efficiency of NK-92 cells is about 50%, even with non-viral methods. Avoiding viral vectors eliminates the risks of oncogene activation and insertional mutagenesis.* ]6 x8 O. J% h
' {8 j5 n8 u3 ~+ u' X
(5) CAR-NK cells can also be produced in large scaleunder GMP conditions. Moerover, it may be used in the setting of allogeneic transplantation.2 z6 s/ q5 v0 k/ x

5 ~* s6 F/ ?- p! S6 h8 ~Naturally, only about 10% of circulating lymphocytes are NK cells. The activation of NK cells is determined by the balance of inhibitory and activating receptor stimulation. MHC class I molecules in normal cells inhibit the activation of NK cells.
- k8 I& W8 V* t" B$ G% l, P6 j
/ L2 r+ g- ?: ~  B3 sNatural NK cells do not express antigen specific receptors. Can CAR-NK cells equipped with an antigen specific receptor kill cancer cells as effectively as CAR-T cells? Hard to say.
, k/ |3 r# F7 X4 B- g( d& J 6 C) i  O+ p: P( ~
Preclinical studies in leukemia, lymphoma, and multiple myeloma have been reported. For instance, treatment with anti-CS1 CAR-NK cells prolonged the survival of multiple myeloma mice from 40 days to 50 days[2].
' |3 K  t. ~( ~/ |
3 X4 q2 Q; Q8 \$ rSorrento intends to develop anti-CD19, anti-PDL1, anti-PSMA, and anti-CD123 CAR-NK cells. It is expected to initiate Phase I trials in 2016.9 I% v7 s$ ]. ]4 N: v3 y
5 F) U7 a0 X% Y3 B' z1 r4 y
[1] Oncoimmunology. 2014, 3, e28147. doi: 10.4161/onci.28147.5 h3 o% {6 f2 F( i2 V2 J
[2] Leukemia. 2014, 28(4), 917-927.
$ T: w2 S- D4 \9 K8 L2 M
( W) L5 _1 }, D$ dRelated Articles:0 Q7 }" N! P$ m/ a& q9 h4 N5 v
What are the next generation T cell immunotherapies
已有 1 人评分威望 包包 收起 理由
细胞海洋 + 2 + 10 极好资料

总评分: 威望 + 2  包包 + 10   查看全部评分

Rank: 2

积分
244 
威望
244  
包包
1350  

金话筒 优秀会员 小小研究员

沙发
发表于 2015-11-12 09:32 |只看该作者
回复 cantonchn 的帖子
3 P. \7 i1 o8 ~- ~0 I
& P. l3 w1 U* \. \0 O8 }3 y, m7 _( E5 {有中文的么?  英文的看起来有点难啊  

Rank: 2

积分
289 
威望
289  
包包
883  

优秀会员

藤椅
发表于 2015-11-12 21:10 |只看该作者
本帖最后由 cneagle66 于 2015-11-12 21:15 编辑 ; v. v+ ]* _% g7 P2 @4 Q( W
4 O) Z+ w' M! P4 l; e
2014年12月15日,Patrick Soon Shiong,世界上最富的医生,获得了Sorrento Therapeutic公司19.9%的股票,每股价格5.80美元,4天后,Sorrento and Conkwest 宣布共同开发CAR-NK免疫疗法,Sorrento的股票价格在2015年1月15上涨到每股11.38美元。
* T' h5 L" O- s' _$ F' l6 B' ~# a- i8 H7 m' N
CAR-T细胞免疫疗法被认为是近年来肿瘤治疗的突破性进展,很多开发CAR-T的公司(如JUNO, KITE, BLCM, BLUE, ZIOP)现在热的发红,Sorrento/Conkwest 正在研发表达CAR的NK细胞,而不是T细胞,CAR-NK和CAR-T相比如何?% A8 E4 b+ W% b9 h8 q4 Q7 d. x/ M

6 M, z7 u+ V: X" l2 E在OncoImmunology上有这样的比较,Hans Klingeman是NK-92细胞系的发明者,和他人在2002年共建了ZelleRx,即2010年更名为Conkwest的公司。CAR-NK具有很多优势:
& R$ \: n) v) F4 _  V 6 g) L' d" n+ c; G3 }0 ?) E
(1)CAR-NK不产生IL-6,后者是细胞因子释放综合征的元凶,CAR-T治疗的临床试验所造成的多起患者死亡,都和IL-6升高有关。- Z: M4 w- d; D' Q: U7 V9 ~) w; c- e) b
/ w7 e( f5 w: C% m
(2) CAR-NK 由于寿命较短,在外周循环中消除较快,不必担心持久的CAR相关的副反应。相应地 JUNO Therapeutics已经着手,插入EGFRt基因以控制CAR-T细胞的效应。2 @8 z" l' d3 f* W6 D$ M- S' P- U
6 ~" j' y$ ]3 N+ z- N
(3)NK细胞是连环杀手,可以聪明地从一个目标移动到另一目标,杀灭7-10个细胞。
0 _# E& S( d/ Q* _' a' ], @4 X8 D+ g. Q) j( ^5 w( o7 g
(4)NK-92细胞的转染效率达50%,甚至是非病毒载体也可轻易转染。不用病毒载体,就避免了癌基因的激活,插入突变等风险。
8 q, S# F& h# @/ N0 X, `& Y% h' }8 h! {4 C: B
(5)CAR-NK也可在GMP状态下批量生产,并可用于异体。
6 L* V5 y4 H0 u1 g: _* ]5 l% Q+ ^6 V  _2 k) [* o; f% R
通常,血循环中只有10%的NK,NK的活化依赖于抑制和活化受体刺激信号之间的平衡,正常细胞中的MHC I类分子抑制NK的活化。
  H9 X5 f9 ^$ B* s* z) \3 e4 Z
天然的NK细胞不表达抗原特异性受体,装备了抗原特异性受体的CAR-NK是不是也和CAR-T一样有效的杀伤癌细胞,还很难说。( |' O& w# H# r" D" R

9 B$ {9 ^( A+ \( f' }; n已经有了临床前的白血病、淋巴瘤、多发性骨髓瘤的报道,如用抗-CS1的CAR-NK治疗,可以延缓多发性骨髓瘤小鼠生存期,从40天延长到50天。
7 L5 u+ Y! B* W" j! F! n
* V" i: G! m3 E' N9 {) NSorrento公司计划开发抗CD19、PD-L1、PMSA、CD123的CAR-NK,预计2016年开始临床I期试验。
已有 1 人评分威望 包包 收起 理由
细胞海洋 + 20 + 50 原创内容

总评分: 威望 + 20  包包 + 50   查看全部评分

Rank: 1

积分
24 
威望
24  
包包
83  
板凳
发表于 2015-11-19 18:27 |只看该作者
学习啦

Rank: 4

积分
1132 
威望
1132  
包包
237  

金话筒 优秀会员

报纸
发表于 2015-11-20 13:46 |只看该作者
回复 cneagle66 的帖子
: \' j% R& c: E, ~% d; ~& X* {6 [. [
; \* Z; S% V1 e外周血中的NK数量应该没有10%这么多,正常在4%~6%之间。
已有 1 人评分威望 包包 收起 理由
细胞海洋 + 2 + 10 欢迎参与讨论

总评分: 威望 + 2  包包 + 10   查看全部评分

Rank: 2

积分
189 
威望
189  
包包
785  
地板
发表于 2020-2-3 12:49 |只看该作者
回复 cantonchn 的帖子
7 C4 A! d  M# D4 [9 k( [
  @$ P: Z& U! t3 V$ ^; N- z+ F也是需要纯化的
‹ 上一主题|下一主题 ›
你需要登录后才可以回帖 登录 | 注册
验证问答 换一个

Archiver|干细胞之家 ( 吉ICP备2021004615号-3 )

GMT+8, 2026-10-30 02:09

Powered by Discuz! X1.5

© 2001-2010 Comsenz Inc.