Cloning Yields Human-Rabbit Hybrid Embryo

bobo

日期: 2003-08-14 今日/总浏览: 1/475( L4 n& I# G; R' B

. Y6 c4 N+ O  G& L3 I* c' U9 h2 F' Z( ~# v

# ?, ], S; e: [# e$ R' E7 ~% |7 o1 i2 o1 {9 [% r! u
ScientistsinChinahave,forthefirsttime,usedcloningtechniquestocreatehybridembryosthatcontainamixofDNAfrombothhumansandrabbits,accordingtoareportinascientificjournalthathasreignitedthesmolderingethicsdebateovercloningresearch.
: j' I  P0 E4 H: R- G& V! u; n! K3 R$ Q. U
Morethan100ofthehybrids,madebyfusinghumanskincellswithrabbiteggs,wereallowedtodevelopinlaboratorydishesforseveraldaysbeforethescientistsdestroyedthemtoretrieveso-calledembryonicstemcellsfromtheirinteriors.AlthoughscientistsinMassachusettshadpreviouslymixedhumancellsandcoweggsinasimilarattempttomakehybridembryosasasourceofstemcells,thoseexperimentswerenotsuccessful.& |1 z2 j& u  Z8 x, m" m

+ b2 D1 B; a# v9 oResearcherssaidyesterdaytheywerehopefulthattherabbitworkwouldleadtoanewandplentifulsourceofembryonicstemcellsforresearchand,eventually,formedicaluse.Buttheologiansandothersdecriedtheworkasunethical.
& g! W7 a# t8 q# n% I% n
/ {3 r6 Z0 k* k1 Z0 E( S' ]8 N) ISomewonderedaloudwhat,exactly,suchacreaturewouldbeifitweretransferredtoawombtodeveloptoterm.
! A' {  g+ K- R. o& V& V
/ c0 K4 i- S' L5 c; |2 zThevastmajorityoftheDNAintheembryosishuman,withasmallpercentageofgeneticmaterial--calledmitochondrialDNA--contributedbytherabbitegg.Nooneknowsifsuchanembryocoulddevelopintoaviablefetus,thoughsomeexperimentswithotherspeciessuggestitwouldnot.7 Z' T* f% M5 F6 ^, S8 l
) M& t' B  G7 \  L
Congresshasbeenmullinglegislationforyearsthatwouldoutlawcertainhumancloningexperiments,withsomeopposedtoanycreationofclonedembryosforresearchandotherssympathetictoresearchusesaslongastheembryosarenotallowedtogrowintoclonedbabies.Nolawhasbeenpassed,however,inpartbecauseofresearchers'warningsthattheproposedrestrictionsaresofar-reachingthattheywouldhobbledevelopmentofnewmedicaltreatments.
# X3 ~, x" ]+ V0 e5 L& f6 s3 C$ |+ i& y
Thenewwork,ledbyHuiZhenShengofShanghaiSecondMedicalUniversity,appearsinthelatestissueofCellResearchandwashighlightedinanewsreportinthejournalNature.CellResearchisapeer-reviewed--iflittle-knownintheUnitedStates--bimonthlyscientificjournalaffiliatedwiththeShanghaiInstituteofCellBiologyandtheChineseAcademyofSciences.Someresearchersyesterdaysaidtheywerefrustratedbythelackofdetailsinthepaper.
0 {! Y2 J& f' B& e! z
+ K; _) h1 U# N: Z1 n4 ITheteamsaiditretrievedforeskintissuefromtwo5-year-oldboysandtwomen,andfacialtissuefroma60-year-oldwoman,asasourceofskincells.TheyfusedthosecellswithNewZealandrabbiteggsfromwhichthevastmajorityofrabbitDNAhadbeenremoved.Morethan400ofthosenew,fusedentitiesgrewintoearlyembryos,andmorethan100survivedtotheblastocyststage--thepointatwhichcovetedstemcellsbegintoform.
5 @( T* h) E4 R9 w8 B4 m* b9 q1 o  {4 s# }, g) y& K4 Y2 F2 U
Theapproachcouldhelpscientistswishingtomass-producehumanembryosassourcesofhumanembryonicstemcells.Stemcellscanmorphintoallkindsoftissuesandmaybeabletoreversetheeffectsofvariousdegenerativediseases.Buttomakeclonedembryos,scientistsneedbothnormalbodycells--suchasskincells--andeggcells,whichhavetheuniquecapacitytoreprogramthegenesinbodycellsandmakethembehaveasthoughtheywereembryocells.
% w8 u, r" O8 j4 A" i" y0 E& X- P5 @. y6 u! a, J
Becausehumaneggcellsaredifficultandcostlytoretrievefromwomen'sovaries--andbecausehumaneggretrievalposesriskstothedonors--scientistshavebeenwantingtoknowwhetheranimaleggsmayserveaswell.AmajorquestionhasbeenwhethertheremnantsofmitochondrialDNAthattypicallyremaininananimaleggwouldbecompatiblewiththenuclearDNAcontributedbythehumancell.4 H: R* T- k# N: P& O- K
% P" i7 _- Y, `; H
Thenewworksuggeststhattheanswertothatquestionisyes,scientistssaid--thoughwithanumberofcaveats.Mostimportant,researcherssaid,thepaperstopsshortofprovingbeyondadoubtthatthestemcellsretrievedfromthehybridembryosaretrulycapableofgrowingforlongperiodsoftimeinlabdishes,andthattheycanturnintoeveryknownkindofcell.  z" n9 s" x: l% y
; F  [) i& h3 v2 D: I1 q
Evenso,saidDouglasMelton,aHarvardUniversitycellbiologistandcloningexpert,theworkisabigadvancebecauseitoffersanewsystemforexploringthemechanismsbywhicheggcellsgetadultcellstoactinembryonicways.Thatcouldprovidedeepinsightsintohumandevelopment,woundhealingandtissueregeneration.
1 f2 |5 D( _. }4 i/ z) R8 Y% o! q* `* [$ ]) Z
Henotedthatalthoughthisisthefirstcreationofahumanchimericembryo--areferencetothefabulouschimeraofGreekmythology,whichhadalion'shead,agoat'sbodyandaserpent'stail--itisnotthefirsttimescientistshaveblendedhumancellsintolabanimals.Somemice,forexample,havebeenendowedwithhumanbraincellsorportionsofthehumanimmunesystemforresearch.
, E1 z$ b8 Z6 r& G/ X
, W% N3 p9 I& jTheChinesework,Meltonsaid,isextremelyinteresting,andIhopetheypursueit.
5 o- R8 R- \7 b5 ]% k8 D- z3 l) Z9 M5 v( ^, r
R.AltaCharo,anassociatedeanoflawandprofessorofbioethicsattheUniversityofWisconsinatMadison,notedthattheworkpassedmusterwithChineseethicsauthorities,whohaddemanded,amongotherthings,thattheembryosnotbeallowedtogrowmorethan14days.
# k0 a0 c8 F( v+ m4 ?
( n$ q% l) `5 n1 h2 r) e, P  ]  b9 D" bShortofputtingoneoftheseembryosintoawoman'sbodyfordevelopmenttoterm,Idon'tthinkthisworkharmsanyonealive,Charosaid.
0 x( y& e' ], E0 e0 f
; `5 f$ }1 |& R* `1 JShesaidtheexperimentsshouldforceopponentsofcloningresearchtoidentifymoreclearlythantheyhaveuntilnowexactlywheretheywoulddrawthelineagainsthumanembryocloning--ineffect:Howhumandoesanembryohavetobetohavethemoralstandingtheseadvocatesconferonembryos?
; E  H: H2 _* y& ~$ ^; [
& ]" i2 J1 m0 p4 v. q) r% K3 ?RichardDoerflinger,oftheU.S.ConferenceofCatholicBishops,saidhefeltcertainthatthehuman-rabbitembryoswerehumanenoughtodeserveprotections.
/ g- I1 g2 ~& l" C
  {5 [& D( b9 PIthinkbecauseallthenuclearDNAishuman,Doerflingersaid,we'dconsiderthisanorganismofthehumanspecies.
5 |: ?* l: i) T  ]9 c7 u' c8 l+ d
( g: m5 @$ w+ _& o# Z+ s& z

% N& p- d& [7 I0 R: ?, C8 X0 t& u3 d% i' L3 X/ a/ Y
. [" t$ h3 k. ^  n5 n' I9 J
作者: Rick Weiss
9 w8 w9 h: _$ A. J来源: Washington Post/ e" z7 ?# H/ F/ Z% |8 I( B
发布者: 亦云